Over $975 Million in Verdicts and Recoveries Over $975 Million in Verdicts and Recoveries
Probe's Focus: Hydraulics
Kevin Dayton, Mary Vorsino and Christie Wilson
The Honolulu Advertiser
3/10/2007



 

        

LIHU'E, Kaua'i — The investigation into the Kaua'i sightseeing helicopter crash that left four dead and three critically injured is likely to focus on the craft's hydraulic system.

Pilot William Joseph "Helicopter Joe" Sulak, of Princeville, Kaua'i, who died in the crash, radioed that he was having problems with his hydraulics. Controlling a helicopter without hydraulics is like driving a car with its power steering off, pilots say. It's possible but takes extra strength.

Two National Transportation Safety Board investigators from the Mainland were to arrive on Kaua'i late yesterday to launch their probe into Thursday's crash at Princeville Airport.

Three couples were riding with Sulak on the Heli USA tour in a A-Star helicopter. One spouse from each couple was killed and one injured.

Police identified the three killed as John O'Donnell of East Rockaway, N.Y.; Teri McCarty of Cabot, Ark.; and Margriet Inglebrecht of Santa Maria, Calif.

Veronica O'Donnell, James McCarty and Cornelius Scholtz, Inglebrecht's husband, survived the crash and are being treated at The Queen's Medical Center. The hospital confirmed it had crash victims under its care, but would not provide any update on their condition.

James Heron, of Princeville, said he was in the emergency room at Wilcox Hospital at the same time the three helicopter victims were brought in. He said two of the victims were unconscious. The third, a man in his 30s, was alert, but had suffered severe injuries to his face. "It looked crushed," Heron said.

Nigel Turner, president of Heli USA, said yesterday that Sulak had successfully landed a helicopter in a hydraulic failure practice just a week before the crash. Sulak, a veteran pilot with an excellent safety record, handled the landing just fine, Turner said, speaking from Las Vegas, where Heli USA is based.

Heli USA suffered a 2002 Arizona crash in which hydraulics were also implicated. In that case, investigators cited a rusted, ungreased hydraulic pump. The NTSB report partly faulted the firm's maintenance procedures. That was one of five A-Star crashes in the past decade in which hydraulics have been an issue.

INVESTIGATION FOCUS
The NTSB probe of Thursday's crash is likely to focus on the A-Star's hydraulics and the procedures followed by Sulak in bringing his ailing helicopter to land. Sulak was reported to have been about two miles from the Princeville Airport when he reported trouble with his hydraulic system. He flew back to the airport, where the copter crashed on a grassy slope next to the paved runway.

No witnesses have come forward to describe the impact. The helicopter ended up facing the runway, with its entire front cockpit crushed, its tail boom broken, one of three main rotors snapped in at least two places, and perched atop two massive yellow inflatable floats. It was not clear yesterday whether the floats had been inflated before the attempted landing or they opened on impact.

The floats are designed for emergency water landings, and one pilot said that once inflated, they cannot be deflated in flight in case the aircraft is able to reach land.

Sulak was a veteran pilot with "a very clean record," said Federal Aviation Administration Pacific region spokesman Ian Gregor. Sulak was flying a seven-seat A-Star model AS350BA helicopter that FAA records show was manufactured in 1979 by Aerospatiale. That company has since been merged into Eurocopter Group.

This will be the fifth NTSB investigation nationwide in 10 years into A-Star helicopters with reports of hydraulic failure — and the second involving a Heli USA aircraft.

Reports differ on whether A-Star hydraulics are at a higher risk of failure than those in other aircraft.

"Its hydraulic system has been criticized in the industry for years, and unless you are a professional weightlifter, you can't maintain rudder control and pedal control without the hydraulics," said Gary Robb, a Kansas City, Mo., attorney who was named last month the national chairman for the Aviation Law Section of the American Association for Justice, formerly the Association of Trial Lawyers of America.

"If you have a hydraulic failure in this aircraft, it's pretty simple: You have uncontrolled flight," said Robb, who is not a pilot and who said he has filed suits against A-Star manufacturer Eurocopter Group.

Others, including the NTSB, differ.

Brian Alexander, a pilot and aviation attorney with the New York law firm of Kreidler and Kreidler, conceded that a hydraulic failure, "when you see that, it's a worst-case scenario for a helicopter pilot. It presents some real problems."

Alexander said he disagrees with Robb that A-Stars are worse than some other aircraft.
"I've flown a Bell Jet Ranger when it had a tail rotor loss of effectiveness. An A-Star is probably not much worse," he said.

Both Alexander and the NTSB say there are established procedures for putting an A-Star down in a case of hydraulic failure.

"If you're in a perfect situation, you can do a run-on landing," which means bringing the helicopter to the ground while still moving forward, rather than stopping all forward movement and hovering to set down. "It's hard to hover" without hydraulic assistance, Alexander said.

FAILURE PROCEDURES
The NTSB, in its investigative report of a 2003 A-Star crash, explained the landing process: "Recommended emergency procedures for a hydraulic system failure dictates that the pilot make a flat approach over a clear landing area and land with slight forward speed."

Heli USA's Turner, himself a pilot, said one problem is that "you can't do a run-on landing with floats. It won't work." He said he did not know whether Sulak's helicopter had its floats inflated before landing, and is interested to find that out.

"An A-Star is an excellent aircraft, but an A-Star without hydraulics is a real handful," he said.

In Boulder, Colo., yesterday, a Las Vegas Helicopters A-Star helicopter lost hydraulic control within 24 hours of the Kaua'i crash, Turner said. That helicopter was able to land safely.

NTSB spokesman Keith Holloway, from Washington, D.C., said that investigator Brian Rayner will lead the agency's inquiry. Normally, after that process is complete, helicopters involved in crashes are loaded onto a flatbed truck and hauled to a secure area — generally a hangar at Lihu'e Airport — where NTSB officials join representatives of the airframe and engine manufacturers and others for a detailed analysis of the aircraft.

The FAA's Gregor said that an FAA investigator was on the island Thursday, but that the NTSB will lead the probe and the FAA would have no statements. Gregor said no one should look for a quick resolution of the cause of the crash.

"These things can take months, into years. It's still early. We don't know what happened," Gregor said.

Staff writers Kevin Dayton, Mary Vorsino and Christie Wilson contributed to this report. Reach Jan TenBruggencate at jant@honoluluadvertiser.com

 




« Back to News & Media

The firm's lawyers are proud to be members of:
Telephone: 816-474-8080
Facsimile: 816-474-8081
TollFree: 1-800-474-1339
Nationwide practice in states including:
Alabama
Arkansas
Florida
Georgia
Hawaii
Illinois
Iowa
Kentucky
Minnesota
Missouri
Nebraska
Nevada
New Mexico
New York
North Carolina
Ohio
Oklahoma
Pennsylvania
Tennessee
Wisconsin

Personal Injury Lawyers - Kansas City, Missouri

Personal injury is an area of law that pertains to the injury of an individual. Both physical and emotional injuries fall into this branch of tort law. A personal injury lawyer is generally involved in cases where an injury has occurred due to the negligence of another party.

Examples of cases that a personal injury lawyer in Kansas City, Missouri can assist with include workplace accidents, falling or other accidents in the home, premises liability, defective and hazardous product cases, and dental and medical malpractice cases. If negligence on behalf of another party can be proved in court, compensation may be awarded.

Personal injury attorneys can also assist with industrial disease cases that may include respiratory diseases or a decline in health due to hazardous occupational conditions. These and other medical cases are often very complex, and it is advised that all aspects of the claim be handled by an experienced attorney.

Wrongful Death Lawyers - Kansas City, Missouri

Wrongful death falls under the common law jurisdictions wherein a person may be held liable for a death. It is important to note that wrongful death is the only course of legal action in which a company, rather than an individual, is at fault for a death.

In Kansas City, Missouri, cases involving wrongful death accidents require a preponderance of evidence as the standard of proof. Generally, the suit is filed by close relatives.

This web site is designed for general information only. The information presented at this site should not be construed to be formal legal advice nor the formation of a lawyer/client relationship. Past results afford no guarantee of future results. Every case is different and must be judged on its own merits.

Robb & Robb LLC One Kansas City Place, Suite 3900 - 1200 Main Street , Kansas City , Missouri 64105

Telephone: 816-474-8080 Facsimile: 816-474-8081 Toll Free: 1-800-474-1339